Women and Asian medics vulnerable to badly fitting masks: report

Agence France-Presse.London | Published: 10:52, Sep 16,2020


Health workers work during a COVID-19 test in a ‘Covid Drive’ at the University Hospital Centre in Rennes, western France, on September 7, 2020. — AFP photo

Women healthcare workers and medical staff with Asian heritage are less likely to be using face masks that fit them properly making them more vulnerable to infection, according to a report on Tuesday calling for more robust equipment testing.

The report published in the journal Anaesthesia looked at studies into different methods used to assess filtration masks like the N95 and FFP2 models, used by medical workers in high risk situations.

The authors said that to ensure a mask was not liable to leak it needed to adequately fit the face shape of the wearer, adding that this appeared to be more important for protection from airborne viral spread than the filtration capacity of the mask itself. 

But hospitals could sometimes lack the time and resources to perform the more rigorous tests, often leaving it up to staff to assess their own equipment.

‘Satisfactory airborne protection will only be provided if the filtering face-piece respirators are properly fitted to the individual’s face, providing a tight facial seal,’ said co-author Prof Britta von Ungern-Sternberg, from the University of Western Australia.

‘Airborne protection is decreased in the presence of a leak as unfiltered air will be drawn inside the mask,’ he added.

Their review drew on pre-pandemic research suggesting that in the highest level ‘fit test’, only 85 percent of women could be fitted with a respirator, compared to 95 percent of men, while men were also more likely to find a suitable mask first time around.

They also looked at other research that showed higher initial fit-pass rates in Caucasians (90 percent) compared with Asians (84 percent) and said that particularly low initial fit-pass rates were reported in Asian women, with a reported average of just 60 percent. 

In the US the report said that authorities use a fit-test panel to assess the suitability of the N95 masks provided to healthcare workers.

But the authors note that the facial dimensions represented by the panel is based on a cohort of people in which women and Asians were ‘underrepresented’. 

In many countries around the world, women made up at least three quarters of all healthcare staff.

The report noted that the full testing of masks was often a standard requirement but suggested that equipment shortages and time constraints in the pandemic had further undermined healthcare authorities’ ability to adequately test respirators.

Health workers had been shown to be at a far higher risk of infection.

Research published in The Lancet Public Health journal in July found that frontline healthcare workers were over three times more likely to test positive in Britain and the US than the general population early in the pandemic, with the rate rising to five times for ethnic minority medical staff. 

That study also found that frontline medical staff who said they that did not have sufficient protective equipment — like masks, gloves and gowns — were 30 per cent more likely to test positive than those who said they had the proper equipment.


More about:

Want stories like this in your inbox?

Sign up to exclusive daily email